Friday, April 27, 2012

Biggest bust potential -- Seahawks take DE/OLB Bruce Irvin

The Seattle Seahawks surprised just about everybody when they took West Virginia DE/OLB Bruce Irvin at #16. Most analysts didn't expect him to be selected until the second round, and Mel Miler immediately called the pick "mind boggling".

ESPN showed some of Irvin's highlights, and while he showed great speed getting after the QB, it looked like he was unblocked on most of his sacks. Also, he looks undersized for a DE, and I think that most offensive linemen (who won't give him free passage to the QB) will be able to contain his speed. Other than the speed rush around the outside, he didn't display any other type of pass rushing moves, such as a rip, swim, or spin.

Ladies and gentlemen, the Seahawks have just found the next Aaron Maybin. Good luck with that.

Bills take CB Stephon Gilmore at #10

The Bills definitely needed help at CB, and Stephon Gilmore has been steadily moving up draft boards since the end of the college season.

He is considered to be the most athletic CB available in the draft, and he doesn't carry the off-field baggage that Dre Kirkpatrick (possible marijuana user) or Janoris Jenkins (definite pot smoker, already has four kids with three different women) have.

This also gives the Bills a very crowded roster at CB, with Aaron Williams, Drayton Florence, Terrence McGee, Leodis McKelvin, and Justin Rogers. At least one of the veterans should be nervous.

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Which way will they go?

With the Bills having already addressed their urgent needs at DE by signing Mario Williams and Mark Anderson, the big question remains as to not only who the Bills might take in the first round, but what position are they considering? Buddy Nix prefers to take the "best player available". The only player mentioned around the top 20 picks that I absolutely do not want, even if he is the BPA, is Trent Richardson. The Bills need another running back like they need a hole in their head. And if Nix picks Richardson, the only possible explanation would be that Nix already *does* have a hole in his head. CJ Spiller is still struggling to get playing time behind Fred Jackson, so the only way Richardson would fit would be to trade away either Jackson or Spiller, and I don't think there's enough value in either of those to justify such a trade. One possibility is for the Bills to take a left tackle. Demetress Bell, having finally spoken up regarding the misspelling of his first name, signed with Philadelphia after Jason Peters blew out his achilles tendon this offseason. Right now, Chris Hairston would be the starter at LT, and while he looked good at times last year, he also looked bad at times. Additionally, the Bills have very little depth at tackle. One prospect, Mike Adams, apparently failed his drug test at the combine. Other than Matt Kalil, the other LT prospects are questionable, perhaps too big of a gamble to take at #10. Besides, if the player they select at #10 can't be an instant starter, then he doesn't have much value. The Bills could pick a wide receiver, adding another weapon to complement Stevie Johnson and make their offense a little less one-dimensional. The Bills struggled to find a solid threat at #2 WR last season, and somebody like Michael Floyd would really make this a potent offense. However, there is a lot of depth at WR this year, so Nix could wait until the second round to grab one. There is the potential to look for an OLB at #10. Kirk Morrison has been penciled in at the strong side position in their new 4-3 defense, but there's definitely room to upgrade. Nick Barnett is the only solid, three-down LB on the team right now, so Courtney Upshaw or Luke Kuechly could be a possibility. One big wild card could be Ryan Tannehill. The Bills desperately need to start finding a long-term solution at QB, the successor to Ryan Fitzpatrick. Many scouts are sold on his ability, but his lack of experience at the college level could be enough to scare Nix away from picking him if he is still on the board.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Bills showing interest in QBs

The Bills are showing interest in several second-tier QBs who will be available in the draft. Michigan State's Kirk Cousins, Arizona State's Brock Osweiler, and now Wisconsin's Russell Wilson are all coming to Buffalo for pre-draft interviews, workouts, and/or physicals.

Cousins was a three-year starter at MSU and played some great games against rival Wisconsin. Osweiler only started for a year, but his raw talent and athletic ability make him an intriguing prospect. Wilson was successful in college, but his height (5'11") makes teams wonder if he can be the next Doug Flutie or if he'll be limited to running a wildcat package. Opinions vary quite a bit on these three. Cousins could go between rounds 2-4, Osweiler from 1-4, and Wilson from 4-6. One thing is almost certain -- the three highest-rated QBs (Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III, and Ryan Tannehill) are almost certain to be gone by the time the Bills get on the clock at #10. Having a run on QBs (similar to the 2011 draft) could push teams to draft a QB a round or two higher than they might have graded that player.

I love that the Bills are checking out the available QB prospects, and I wonder if there are any others they are looking at, such as Nick Foles or Case Keenum. Tyler Thigpen should be the #3 QB on the depth chart, not #2. The Bills really need to find somebody who can take over from Ryan Fitzpatrick in a few years, and Thigpen isn't it.

Sunday, April 1, 2012

Arizona State QB Brock Osweiler - prospect or suspect

There seems to be quite a difference of opinion on Arizona State QB Brock Osweiler.

Some scouts view him as a borderline first-round talent, others see him as a fourth round pick. He has the physical tools -- he's 6'7", possesses a strong arm, and has mobility. (He was once a basketball prospect.) However, he was only a one-year starter at ASU, and his game tape shows that he has some trouble reading defenses and will stand in the pocket too long, leading to avoidable sacks.

The bottom line is that this is a guy who is not ready to start right away in the NFL. But for the Bills, that's okay. Ryan Fitzpatrick will be the starter this year unless he gets injured -- and even then, it's no guarantee that he will sit. (He played through broken ribs last year because an injured Fitzpatrick is still better than a healthy Tyler Thigpen.)

The Bills should be looking for a QB who they can develop into a starter a few years from now, and Osweiler fits that bill. The Bills sent scouts to four separate ASU games last season, and Osweiler is one of the prospects that the Bills plan to bring to Buffalo for a pre-draft interview.

Osweiler is definitely on the Bills' radar. The question is how much do they like him, and do they like him more than another team that wants to draft a QB?

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

AFC East QBs just colletively wet their pants

The Bills signed DE Mark Anderson to a 4-year deal today. He played for the New England Patriots last season, registering 10 sacks during the regular season and 2.5 more in the playoffs. Although he has been somewhat inconsistent in the years between last season and his rookie year, he is certainly capable of getting after a quarterback.

Tom Brady, Mark Sanchez, and whoever the Dolphins start at QB this year have got to be worried. If this line can stay healthy, this could be one of the most dominating lines in the league. Mario Williams will start at left end, Kyle Williams and Marcel Dareus as the tackles, and a combination of Chris Kelsay, Shawne Merriman, and now Anderson at right end.

The Bills had an anemic pass rush at the end of last season. Right now, I can't wait to see this unit in action. John Beck of the Washington Redskins was the only QB to feel the wrath of this unit last season, but there could be a lot of banged-up QBs by the time next season is over.

Buddy Nix had hinted that the Bills were more likely to take a DE in the middle rounds of the draft, but now they might not need to draft one at all. They still need some help at LT if they don't re-sign Demetrius Bell, and WR, CB, OLB, and QB of the future all look much more important for the draft. I hope they can bring Bell back so they have more flexibility in the draft. Nobody wants to be required to draft a player, they want the freedom to choose the one they like the most.

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Tebowmania comes to a sudden end

With Peyton Manning poised to join the Denver Broncos, GM John Elway is going to trade Tim Tebow to the highest bidder. Or, quite possibly, *any* bidder. Some analysts think they will be lucky if they even get a fifth round pick for the former first round pick. And if they can't get a draft pick for him, they may just cut him from the roster.

So how does a quarterback who led his team to a playoff victory suddenly find himself on the outside looking in? He has great leadership skills, but he's just not an NFL quarterback. He can't read defenses, his mechanics are awful, and his accuracy is terrible because he can't throw a spiral. He could be a fullback, H-back, or tight end. He could be dangerous for reverses and option passes. He could also be dangerous as a wildcat quarterback where running is far more likely than passing. He just won't ever be a pocket passer.

Some fans are blinded by the results in Denver. "He just wins." Hey, don't forget the other 52 guys on the active roster. Denver had a very strong defense last year that kept their games close enough for Tebow to pull out last-minute victories. If you look at how he played for the rest of the game, it wasn't good. With Manning at QB, the Broncos immediately become favorites to win the AFC West. They won't be worried about last-minute victories because they should be able to blow opponents away.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Welcome, Super Mario!

The Bills finally got a deal done with DE/OLB Mario Williams. I was afraid that if he left town without a done deal, he wouldn't be coming back. The Bills talked him into staying an extra night, and they finally made him an offer he couldn't refuse.

One of the most glaring weaknesses in the 2011 Bills' defense was their pass rush. For the second straight season, a DT led the team in sacks... and it wasn't a very big total. Opposing quarterbacks had more than enough time to scan the field, and cornerbacks were asked to cover for way too many seconds. As a result, almost every opposing quarterback put up spectacular numbers.

With Mario at DE in a 4-3, opposing QBs won't feel so confident this year. Marcell Dareus and Kyle Williams are both playmakers in the middle, and Chris Kelsay, Shawne Merriman, and possibly a rookie DE will provide pressure from the other side. Suddenly, the Bills have a defensive line that other teams will fear.

I like what GM Buddy Nix is doing to rebuild this team. He started with the draft, and now he's using free agency to fill in the major gaps. It's a shame that they didn't get WR Robert Meachem, but I'm glad they made the effort to do whatever it took to get Mario Williams to sign. Hopefully, they can find another WR, LT, or CB in free agency so that they can use the draft to add depth and continue to build for the future.

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Bills targeting Mario Williams

The Buffalo Bills entertained DE/OLB Mario Williams last night, although they were unable to make him an offer he couldn't refuse. They did make a huge offer -- the largest (potential) free agent contract in franchise history. They will continue to meet with him this morning in an effort to convince him to sign the contract. He has one more visit scheduled. It isn't clear where else he is going, but I get the feeling that the Bills need to sign him before he can go anywhere else. Once he leaves Buffalo, the odds of signing him go down dramatically.

Meanwhile, Buddy Nix also targeted Saints' WR Robert Meachum. Unfortunately, he signed with San Diego as a replacement for Vincent Jackson (who signed with Tampa Bay).

Nix said that he was after two specific people, and now we know who they are. However, it isn't clear if he will pursue anybody else at WR or if he will target a different position -- such as LT -- to reduce the need to draft specific positions.

It's great to see Nix and the Bills pursuing big-name, impact players, but unless they can actually sign one, it becomes nothing more than fancy talk.

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

On your marks... Get set... Sign!

Today marks the first day of the new league year. As such, contracts that do not extend into the 2012 season expire today, meaning that there will be a bunch of free agents available to sign this afternoon. Buddy Nix has said that he plans to aggressively pursue impact players, and the Bills are in the top ten teams for available cap space.

Most of the potential Bills free agents were resigned. The notable exceptions are LT Demetrius Bell and SS/LB Bryan Scott. While they could sign elsewhere, there is a distinct possibility that they will still end up back with the Bills. Both appear to have limited value as free agents, especially Bell with his injury history.

The Bills two biggest needs are DE and WR, so Mario Williams and Vincent Jackson are going to be the primary targets. There is a deep pool of WRs this year, so if they fail to get Jackson, there are good alternatives. The Bills might also go after an offensive tackle, a cornerback, a strong-side OLB, and some overall depth.

The more they can do in free agency, the less they are forced into taking certain players in the draft. Nix prefers to take the "best player available" in the draft, but if he can't address the team's most urgent needs, his draft choices will be forced upon him. Let's see if he will be able to come through with some impact players.

Monday, March 12, 2012

How Peyton Manning could affect the Bills

No, this isn't an article imploring the Bills to sign Petting Manning. Far from it. Although a healthy Manning could quickly turn the Bills into a contender, the reality is that he is still battling neck injuries that may never heal 100%, and even if they do, they would still be better off in the long run by grooming a prospect to take over in a few years.

Still, the Bills need to worry about where Manning ends up. Obviously, the Patriots don't need him, but both the Jets and Dolphins have expressed an interest. Both are teams that would spend whatever it takes to bring him in and compete head-to-head with Tom Brady. What a nightmare that would be for the Bills (and whichever other AFC East team failed to sign him) -- having to play against both Brady *and* Manning twice each year.

Fortunately for the Bills, it looks like Manning will not end up signing with a division rival. The Jets just reworked Mark Sanchez' contract, and neither team has a lot of cap room to spare. Both have about $10m available, but they will still need room for signing other free agents and their eventual draft picks. Also, while Manning has no apparent interest in visiting the Jets, he has thus far avoided visiting Miami. He said that it was because he was familiar with their facilities, but I don't see how he could possibly consider them without at least meeting the coaching staff face-to-face.

Friday, March 9, 2012

TE Scott Chandler re-signs

The Bills kept the tight end position from turning into another hole by re-signing Scott Chandler to a two-year deal. There would have been very few quality free agents to replace him, so the talent level would have almost certainly declined. Chandler is primarily known for his blocking ability, but he had a fantastic start last season as a red zone target. However, in typical Bills fashion, he became an afterthought in the play calling during second half of the season.

One of the Bills' best tight ends ever, Pete Metzelaars, returns to the Bills this year as a coach. Hopefully, he can get Chandler up to the next level and make him into a more consistent receiver.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Potential QBs of the Future

As I mentioned in my last blog, Ryan Fitzpatrick is the "QB of the Present". However, nobody else on the roster represents the "QB of the Future". Despite the long-term contract extension Fitz signed last season, I would be surprised (and probably a bit disgruntled) if the Bills got more than two or three more years out of him. So, this year's draft would be a great time to find one to start grooming to take over that role.

Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III appear to be locks for the #1 and #2 overall picks (especially if the Rams trade down from #2). Here are the remaining possibilities:

* Ryan Tannehill - He is considered a first round pick, but he is *way* too much of a risk for GM Buddy Nix to take a chance on him at #10. He switched to WR to start his college career, and he didn't switch back until midway through 2010. As a result, he only played 20 games at QB. He recently underwent foot surgery, so he missed the Senior Bowl and could not work out at the combine. They did measure him at the combine, and one thing they found was that he has small hands, so that could make him a fumble risk. Nix strongly prefers players with consistent college production (aka -- "body of work"), so even though scouts think Tannehill could be a superstar in a few years, I expect Nix to pass and fill a more pressing need.

* Brock Osweiler - He has been quietly moving up scouting draft boards, but I think the Bills have had him on their radar all of last season. They apparently sent scouts on four separate occasions to watch him play at Arizona State. He is so tall (6'7") that scouts are concerned, but he has the arm strength and surprising mobility. His numbers at ASU were good, although a 2:1 TD-to-INT ratio is probably a reason why he might not go in the first round. If he is still available in round two, I would be very excited if the Bills grab him. He would not be ready to start right away, but the Bills wouldn't need him to.

* Brandon Weeden - All you need to know about Weeden is his age. Having originally attempted a baseball career, he returned to college to play football. As a result, he will be 29 at the start of this season. If not for his age, he could have been a first round pick. Instead, he will need to go to a team where he can start right away, and that's not going to happen in Buffalo.

* Kirk Cousins - His stock rose at the combine, but there is nothing spectacular about him. When pressured, he made bad decisions and threw interceptions. He might be okay if he has an offensive line where he will be given time to throw, but that isn't Buffalo's current game plan. If he falls to round four, the Bills might think about him... but I doubt it.

* Nick Foles - In order for some guys to move up the draft board, some guys have to move down. Foles is one of those guys. He has a great arm, but he's not very mobile and does force passes at times. He needs to work on his field vision and going through progressions. If the Bills wanted a pocket passer like Drew Bledsoe, this could be their guy. Unfortunately, I think he would be getting sacked as often as Bledsoe did, so this probably isn't a good fit, even if he does fall to the middle rounds.

* Russell Wilson - He's 5'11". His height will be a huge factor, and Nix is a guy that loves measurables. So, I don't expect him to show any love here.

* Case Keenum - No QB ever put up college numbers like Keenum. He threw for 5,000+ yards not just once, but three times -- all while throwing to no-name receivers who probably won't make it to the NFL. His 48:5 TD-to-INT ratio this year was phenomenal. The knocks against him are questionable arm strength (so is Fitzpatrick's), he played in a spread formation out of the shotgun (as did Fitz), and played against inferior talent in Conference-USA. Still, he finished his career at Houston with a dominating performance against Penn State, although they may have been a bit distracted with the Sandusky revelations. With his consistent production at the the college level, I would be very excited if the Bills could grab him in a later round. He seems like a quarterback who would fit right in with the Bills' system, and his TD-to-INT ratio shows he can make good decisions.

If the Bills don't draft a QB this year, there will be some good choices next year... but if they are in a position to draft in the top five, then Nix and Chan Gailey probably won't be around any more.

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

The QB conundrum -- present and future

Barring injury or other unforseeable circumstances, Ryan Fitzpatrick is the Bills' QB of the present. When he's on, he's very good. When he's off, he's awful. Sadly, he is also inconsistent, and we never know if "Good Fitz" or "Bad Fitz" will show up to play. He is, by far, the best QB currently on their roster. They just gave him a huge contract extension, but the reality is that they probably won't get more than two or three years out of him before he will need to be replaced. That's why the Bills need to start looking for the QB of the future.

Tyler Thigpen, currently #2 on the depth chart, isn't it. He has been in the league for several years now, and the only thing he brings to the table is game experience. Unfortunately, most of it is bad. His career record is 1-11 (most of that from when he was a starter at Kansas City), and from what I've seen, he got that record on merit. With the Bills, he looked awful right from his very first preseason action, and it is obvious that the only reasons why he made the roster were because they desperately needed a backup QB and Gailey was his offensive coordinator at both KC and Miami. (Yay cronyism!) Thigpen is neither the present nor the future of the Bills, and he is wasting a roster spot with his presence.

#3 on the depth chart is WR Brad Smith. Yes, he's a wide receiver. His presence on the QB depth chart is entirely based on running the wildcat, although he only threw one pass for the entire season. (It was intercepted. Way to go, Brad.) Although he had good success running the ball (but only when decisive about it), he should stick to being a wide receiver. Nobody would ever ask him to throw for 3,000+ yards in a season. The Bills should be using him more for reverses and throwing from a reverse.

The Bills really need to start looking at drafting a QB this year. They fell short of not only the "Suck for Luck" sweepstakes, but Robert Griffin III will be gone as well. However, there will still be some interesting choices available to the Bills... maybe not at #10, but starting in round two. Next time, I'll review some of the possibilities.

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Does the Bell toll for thee, Buddy Nix?

Now that Stevie Johnson has re-signed, LT Demetrius Bell becomes the next potential free agent to worry about. The Bills are set at RT with Erik Pears signed to a long-term deal, and backup LT Chris Hairston has several years left on his rookie contract. They have Sam Young, a little-known backup to Pears, but that's it for offensive tackles. Although Bell has been injury-prone, his level of play -- when healthy -- is superior to Hairston's.

Once again, the Bills are in a position where failing to retain a quality player creates another problem that needs to be addressed through free agency or the draft. Quality free agents at LT can be very expensive, so they would probably be forced to find one in the draft. And while they are three very good LT prospects this year, of which, at least one should be available at #10, the Bills already have urgent issues they need to address. Failing to sign Bell means that they will almost certainly be forced to draft one in the first round, forcing DE, WR, OLB, CB, and potential franchise QB to later rounds where the Bills are less likely to find a starter, let alone a superstar.

It is possible that Bell's penchant for injuries will scare other teams away, and he may still sign with the Bills. It just seems senseless to take that risk and open the potential for creating yet another need.

Monday, March 5, 2012

Stevie Johnson re-signs

Buffalo Bills sign Stevie Johnson

The Bills finally worked out a deal with Stevie Johnson, and this is great news for the team. The Bills have enough problems to address through free agency and the draft, so why create additional problems by letting their best wide receiver go to another team through free agency? Sure, he may have some maturity issues, but he is still a dangerous receiver capable of putting even Darrelle Revis to shame. Although there will be several good wide receivers available through free agency, there are no guarantees that any of them would sign with Buffalo. Also, it would be so much nicer to complement Stevie Johnson with one of them instead of replacing him.

If the Bills want to continue making forward progress, then it is imperative that they retain the talent they have and build upon it. Otherwise, they are just spinning their wheels.